racking up the list
2 Jan 2007 03:35 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Actually, with maybe one or two books I've forgotten (because they were that forgettable), here's what I squeezed into my brain managed to read in the past year. Yowser. Plus, comments, just because, but trying to be fair whenever possible. (Besides, if you have recommendations for me, this'll tell you what did, and did not, appeal to me & why.)
EDIT: forgot one. Tells you something that I'd blocked out memory so thoroughly of it. Added it to end of fiction list. Asterisks indicate those books I finished only by skimming, just out of sheer obstinancy -- whether this meant just the last few chapters, or the entire second half, and by reading every few paragraphs or random pages here and there, I ain't saying. Suffice it to say, books with asterisks are ones where finishing took concerted effort on my end.
Part of the reason I read so much was a) this 52-book challenge going around, which prompted much moaning from participants that they'd never, ever get that many books read! And b) the realization that if I'm going to keep from treading the same tired tropes myself, I need to be aware of what's out there. It's not competition per se, so much as "what is being read/sold".
I was going to ponder what I'd learned from what I've read, but I'll save that for a later post. Now I just need a chance to boggle.
EDIT: forgot one. Tells you something that I'd blocked out memory so thoroughly of it. Added it to end of fiction list. Asterisks indicate those books I finished only by skimming, just out of sheer obstinancy -- whether this meant just the last few chapters, or the entire second half, and by reading every few paragraphs or random pages here and there, I ain't saying. Suffice it to say, books with asterisks are ones where finishing took concerted effort on my end.
- A Game of Thrones, George R. R. Martin.
- A Clash of Kings, George R. R. Martin.
- A Storm of Swords, George R. R. Martin.
◦ George R R Martin
Plus: Understands the concept of throwing rocks at characters.
Minus: Throws boulders.
Read more? Possibly. Uncertain about rumors that next book is two parts & neglects my favorite characters. - Black Sun Rising*
◦ CS Friedman
Plus: Intriguing premise.
Minus: Character motivations not convincing.
Read more? Doubtful. - Nightlife*
◦ Rob Thurman
Plus: Strong character voice.
Minus: Needs lots more work on economics of underground.
Read more? Maybe. Will wait for reviews this time. - Paladin of Souls
- The Curse of Chalion
◦ Lois McMaster Bujold
Plus: No one is clearly good or clearly bad; complex intrigue.
Minus: Sometimes gets lost with so many characters.
Read more? Eventually. - His Majesty's Dragon
- Black Powder War
- Throne of Jade
◦ Naomi Novik
Plus: Excellent twist on dragon genre and Napoleonic historical fiction.
Minus: background characters often too background.
Read more? Absolutely. - Valiant
◦ Holly Black.
Plus: This woman can make you taste the grit between your teeth.
Minus: The bad mother trope is a standard of YA, but really not my thing.
Read more? Absolutely! - Last Light of the Sun
- Sailing to Sarantium*
◦ Guy Gavriel Kay
Plus: Gorgeously researched.
Minus: Ponderous, loves the editorializing.
Read more: Thanks, but not my thing. - Smoke and Shadows
- Blood Price
- Blood Trail
- Blood Pact
- Blood Debt
◦ Tanya Huff
Plus: bisexual protag.
Minus: Just because you're pretty much it when it comes to urban fantasy with strong and rounded GLBT characters doesn't mean you can slack on filling plotholes.
Read more? I've read enough, but I could be convinced by a trusted friend, maybe.
- King Rat
◦ China Mieville
Plus: Melts English into fantastical combination of archaic and slang that works.
Minus: his politics got in the way of his story.
Read more? Doubtful. - Compass Rose
- Barbed Rose
◦ Gail Dayton
Plus: well-rounded world-building, fascinating relationship concepts
Minus: veers just a little close to Mary Sue at times
Read more? Yes. Totally. - The Gypsy*
◦ Steven Brust & Megan Lindholm
Plus: Wait, something will come to me. Poetic language, perhaps.
Minus: First half of book could've been cut and nothing lost.
Read more? Not if the others are anything like this one. - Giants of the Frost
◦ Kim Wilkins
Plus: entrancing, suspenseful, cool take on Norse legends
Minus: on the bleak side, main character a little neurotic (though that did work in context)
Read more? If I'm certain other works also have fantasy element; she normally writes 'paranormal romance', which isn't my thing - Moon Called
◦ Patricia Briggs
Plus: For once, the werewolves aren't better than humans, nor all "in touch with nature" crap
Minus: They're still werewolves.
Read more? maybe, could be convinced by any friends who read it first - Something from the Nightside*
◦ Simon R. Green
Plus: Urban fantasy with only hints at intricate backstory.
Minus: Unable to stop shoving hints at intricate foreboding backstory down my frickin' throat.
Read more? Pretty much a no. - Perfect Circle
- Mockingbird
◦ Sean Stewart
Plus: Amazing quirky human characters, believable fantastical magical realism
Minus: Stories keep ending, damn it.
Read more? You got it. - Bedlam's Bard*
◦ Mercedes Lackey, Rosemary Edghill
Plus: Uhm, okay, among the first to really mix fantastical into modern urban setting
Minus: Oh, look, another frickin' Renfest addict character. And the italics, how they burn!
Read more? You'd have to pay me. - Strange Adventures of Rangergirl
◦ Tim Pratt
Plus: quirky, engaging main character, peculiar and different premise
Minus: Walked the edge of 'writer writing about writer' with instead 'writer writing about comic-book writer'
Read more? Possibly. - A Prince Among Men*
◦ Robert Charrette
Plus: Concept. That's about it.
Minus: Everything else.
Read more? No. Just no. - Tropic of Night
- Night of the Jaguar
- Valley of Bones
◦ Michael Gruber
Plus: Amazing crossover between fantastical/magical-realism, police procedure, thriller, and anthropological treatises.
Minus: Can go a bit thin when mixing magic into finale, walking the line on magic ex machina.
Read more? Hell yeah. - The Traveler
◦ John Twelve Hawks
Plus: Gibson's love child + cool take on modern world to create believeable paranoia
Minus: A little too paranoid at times, just something in the tone...
Read more? Possibly. - Storm Front
- Fool Moon
- Grave Peril
- Summer Knight
◦ Jim Butcher
Plus: Harry is a screwup, deadpan humor rocks, and even tangential characters are strongly written
Minus: Introducing new characters in later books is done awkwardly.
Read more? only because reviews/critics say his 5th book is the strongest in the series - Heroics for Beginners
◦ John Moore
Plus: Skews every possible fantasy cliche.
Minus: Can't see I'd want more; one was enough.
Read more? doubtful; reviews indicate his next books are the same schtick - Hard Rain
- Rain Storm
- Killing Rain
◦ Barry Eisler
Plus: Awesomely multicultural, with strong feeling of been-there
Minus: Goes a little overboard on the fighting/guns details, verging on showing-off
Read more? Hell yeah. - Nine Layers of Sky
◦ Liz Williams
Plus: bleak, wintry setting; fascinating twist; unusual protags
Minus: love story wasn't nearly as developed -- rushed at points, that is
Read more? Possibly. - Playback
◦ Raymond Chandler
Plus: dude, it's Raymond Chandler.
Minus: the guy is dead and I've read all his work now.
Read more? Guess I'm stuck with rereading... - The Anubis Gates
◦ Tim Powers
Plus: Contains everything and the kitchen sink, and three llamas in there somewhere.
Minus: A few chapters near the end had distinct "oh shit have to finish soon" feeling.
Read more? yes - Gun with Occassional Music
- Amnesia Moon*
◦ Jonathan Lethem
Plus: Love child of Hunter Thompson and Raymond Chandler, on acid.
Minus: Needs some serious work on providing an ending...any ending.
Read more? No, sadly. - Once Upon Stilletos
◦ Shanna Swendson
Plus: great voice, still kooky, still down-to-earth girl in city, still charming
Minus: the series' arc-villian plot is starting to look rather thin
Read more? hell yeah - Bourne Identity
- Bourne Ultimatum
◦ Robert Ludlum
Plus: Damn, I didn't see that coming...or that...or that...
Minus: Verges on over-involved, glossing potential plotholes
Read more? Yep! - Melusine
◦ Sarah Monette
Plus: Excellent character voice, great portrayal of (magical-induced) madness
Minus: Dragged; diverging stories needed to merge earlier, somehow
Read more? Depends on reviews/critiques - Privilege of the Sword
◦ Ellen Kushner
Plus: Believable main protag, complex intrigue
Minus: Still verges on melodrama at times.
Read more? maybe, if friends recommend - Dragon's Eye
◦ James Hetley
Plus: strong lesbian characters, evocative setting/description
Minus: The Mary Sue! Kill it! Kill it!
Read more? no - Staying Dead
- Curse the Dark
- Bring it On*
◦ Laura Anne Gilman
Plus: strong female character, capable handling of secondary characters
Minus: tertiary characters blend; yet another Sekkrit Organizashun Running Everything
Read more? not sure; getting tired of Sekkrit Org trope. - Lies of Locke Lamora
◦ Scott Lynch
Plus: snarky, up-to-no-good inventive and immoral protags, yay; secondary characters not TSTL
Minus: ending a bit too pat and/or quick compared to build-up
Read more? yes - Song of the Beast
◦ Carol Berg
Plus: Really did manage to keep plot/motivation simple and withhold payoff for 300+ pages.
Minus: Background characters sometimes became mix-and-match.
Read more? yes - Rush*
◦ Kim Wozenkraft
Plus: intense, pulled no punches
Minus: some end to the bleakness, please, and enough with the TSTL
Read more? no thanks. - Path of Blood
◦ Diana Pharaoh Francis
Plus: strong female character, didn't flinch on consequences
Minus: Single POV can = unreliable narrator can = unexpected behaviors from secondary characters
Read more? yep, rest of series is sitting right here! - Singer of Souls
◦ Adam Stemple
Plus: Different take on power of music, drug use, fairy world
Minus: Ending was distinctly emotionally unsatisfying
Read more? maybe - Living Next Door to the God of Love*
◦ Justina Robson
Plus: Interesting premise, some gorgeous turns of phrase.
Minus: Even the entire thesaurus won't mask an ignorance of physics in a story whose lynchpin is physics: ends up a lot of pretty words signifiying jack.
Read more? Ha, ha. Not unless Robson's been cut off from Scientific American and Babbelfish.
NONFICTION - Trust Me
◦ Richard Ratcke - Phoenix: Cesare Borgia: His Life and Times
◦ Sarah Bradford - Undercover and Alone
◦ William Queen - Hot Shots and Heavy Hits
◦ Paul Doyle - Without A Badge: Undercover in the World's Deadliest Criminal Organization
◦ Jerry Speziale - Speed Tribes
◦ Karl Taro Greenfeld - Alec Baldwin Doesn't Love Me
◦ Michael Thomas Ford - Cesar's Way
◦ Cesar Millan - Do You Speak American?
◦ Robert MacNeil
DIDN'T FINISH
FICTION
- Princess of Roumania
◦ Paul Park
Why: because I couldn't make heads nor tails of the opening chronology, and two chapters of a whole lotta telling with scant showing was enough to disincline me to keep going. - Nightwatch
◦ Sergei Lukyanenko
Why: it felt like...the kind of thing that, in the US, would get sent back with a note to investigate writer's critique groups. Good premise, needs work. In Russia, perhaps it was so unusual this made its flaws forgiveable; perhaps its translator just couldn't grasp subtleties so used simple third-grade words, which compounded a rather sparse characterization style. - The Black Tattoo
◦ Sam Enthoven
Why: because if I want a he's-the-chosen-one Mary Sue story filled with cardboard stereotypes and rushed development, I'll go read some fanfiction. - The Levanter
◦ Eric Ambler
Why: I'd just come off reading Ludlum and Eisler; Ambler's style is far slower and more thoughtful. I just couldn't adjust, I suppose. - The Polish Officer
◦ Alan Furst
Why: Same as for Ambler, though Furst's characterizations, premise, and setting are masterfully done. - Pattern Recognition
◦ William Gibson
Why: I wanted to like it, I really did. But I paused to do something else...and never went back. One chapter in, and I still hadn't hit that, "I wonder what's going to happen" feeling. - The Birth of Venus
◦ Sarah Dunant
Why: Unbelievably gratuitous historical inaccuracies that jarred me so much I wanted to mail the book back to the author with a note: "feminism? Newsflash: twentieth-century concept. Really." - The Borgia Bride
◦ Jeanne Kalogridis
Why: Lucrezia Borgia as a jealous, rapacious, poisoning evil-doer -- a slander debunked for some time now. Find another villian, please, she's been villianized enough. - The Night Manager
◦ John le Carré
Why: Everything hinged on me believing the protag would uproot his life to kill this one guy. A third of the way in, I still didn't believe it. Nuff said. - Outside the Dog Museum
◦ Jonathan Carroll
Why: Just couldn't get into it. Tried, failed, maybe will try later. Haven't traded the book in, at least.
Part of the reason I read so much was a) this 52-book challenge going around, which prompted much moaning from participants that they'd never, ever get that many books read! And b) the realization that if I'm going to keep from treading the same tired tropes myself, I need to be aware of what's out there. It's not competition per se, so much as "what is being read/sold".
I was going to ponder what I'd learned from what I've read, but I'll save that for a later post. Now I just need a chance to boggle.