Thanks for this. I find your posts really interesting and thought provoking. But... Why the reluctance to name names? This reads to me as something of a review/anti-rec, and as someone (like you) who WOULD pick this up for the subject matter, headsup on blatant stupidity are always appreciated. I understand the concern when you're discussing authorial intent (and lazyiness) but maybe they should be called on it? Just wondering.
no subject
Date: 2 Jul 2009 07:11 pm (UTC)Why the reluctance to name names? This reads to me as something of a review/anti-rec, and as someone (like you) who WOULD pick this up for the subject matter, headsup on blatant stupidity are always appreciated.
I understand the concern when you're discussing authorial intent (and lazyiness) but maybe they should be called on it?
Just wondering.